Why Dark Themes and Terminals can Strain your Eyes
July 07, 2007 around 12am (openSUSE)I tend to regularly find myself in discussions or read blog posts where it is suggested that dark themes are “easier on the eyes” and hence a better way to go. While a darker theme means that there is less light entering your eyes, in general a dark theme can cause more problems.
Most desktop themes are all light-coloured. This is not only true on Windows, but with GNOME and KDE. Furthermore, around 99% of websites at least have a light-coloured background as well. Now, when you have a large dark terminal open, or your own website theme which is dark as well, you will inevitably have to go to a new webpage frequently which is incredibly bright in contrast. Or, you might launch another application.
You might have a dark theme for your favourite desktop environment, but even so it is a lot harder to escape the majority of websites which are not dark. When you do end up launching such a website, the pupillary light reflex causes your pupils to contract very quickly. The amount of light entering the eye suddenly increases (even more so in darker conditions), and persistent occurence of this as a sudden transition can strain your eyes. This is not too dissimilar to going for a sprint without jogging first. For this reason a well-lit work area is just as important: that is, for when you look away from the monitor and back.
Now, I do not want to imply here that a purely white wallpaper, theme, or website background is ideal. A more ideal colour is one that is just off-white, to reduce glare which can also cause eyestrain and vision difficulties.
RSIBreak is also a nice application that helps you avoid repetitive strain injury.
Interesting read, however this is not the case with me here. I *always* use dark color schemes in KDE (been using them for years) and while sudden bright light indeed gets the pupils contract very quickly, I personally find darker schemes to relax more than brighter ones. For example, I tend to spend many hours behind a PC monitor on a daily basis. While I was using bright default color schemes in the past, after many hours behind the monitor my head starts to hurt. When I switched using dark schemes, I never got any headaches again. Personally, I don’t have any problems with bright Web sites and dark color schemes on my desktop. It is true that when the human eyes receive very little light, the brain starts producing chemicals which make you sleepy and more relaxed and sudden bright light can introduce disturbance in this process. However, the PC monitor produces enough light (even in the case of dark schemes) to not fully make these chemicals kick in. I never use any of these really dark, almost completely black color schemes, and my colors are well balanced here. Again, I speak for myself and others can react differently on light or dark color schemes
-ppi
Thanks for sharing. Very bright themes can also be very bad for you indeed. The problem with dark themes is not only that you might be less responsive or more sleepy with them (though this is an issue — most studies I’ve seen tend to show surprising results with blue backgrounds in contrast to other ones), but also that such a quick transition of the amount of light entering the eye can really strain them when it is done repetitively.
It would be quite nice to see a typical screenshot of your desktop to see exactly what colour of theme you have going there. I’m not sure myself of what exactly is ideal (I haven’t seen any research on this), but either extreme — to dark or too light — is indeed harmful.
Indeed, balanced out colors are the best way to go, but I use darker schemes mostly for their coolness factor
Here are some shots of my desktop. As you can see in the first image, my wallpaper is pretty bright, even though it’s a dark wallpaper. The second image shows how I see your page from here
Desktop: http://img59.imageshack.us/img59/2355/dvd1ls3.png
Firefox: http://img369.imageshack.us/img369/9776/dvd2ur3.png
Indeed, that is pretty dark (though there are darker themes). Changing between those two tabs (each with one of those images) a few times makes me a little dazed, and I’m in a reasonably well-lit area. It doesn’t bother you?
Nope, not at all. I never had any issues when switching from my darker desktop to a bright Web page… Also, when I work for long and I use a bright color scheme, it tends to hurt my eyes more than when using a dark scheme and switching to a bright Web page from time to time. I get a slightly itching and burning effect in my eyes - too much light for a long period I guess, but the light color schemes I have are all default ones, meaning not too bright and not too dark
Jaki Degg…
I Googled for something completely different, but found your page…and have to say thanks. nice read….
RSI on eyes? I never thougt about this - but you’re right. I’m a computer programmer. After two years of RSI hand wrist pain I was able to heal it. Thanks for that tipp for RSI on eyes.
I have similar feeling regarding dark themes as ppi. In order to have web pages a bit darker, I use + to adjust brightness. It requires compiz, but works pretty well.
Also you can use color invert for browser’s window (also in compiz).
OK. I used HTML tags in the previous comment
“(…) I use [ctrl]+[mouse wheel] (…)”